When I was a teenager acting out the customary role as Future Comic Artist (by which I mean copying and memorizing individual poses out of comic books), it was unsurprising that I became obsessed with the idea of anatomy. I felt that "learning all the muscles" was going to magically make me a better artist, though it seemed like a daunting and impossible task. I dutifully copied some diagrams from an anatomy book, and felt a little tinge of pride knowing what a deltoid was, or that the calf muscle was called the gastrocnemius (I skipped over the soleus). However, I had skipped over two huge facets of anatomy: the skeleton, and perspective.
George Bridgman used a brilliant phrase as the title of one of his books on drawing the figure: "The Human Machine". It's a good way to think about the figure. From a sculptural point of view, a good exercise would be to build an actual machine out of metal and wood that mimics the functionality and range of motion of the human skeleton, using parts you find at the hardware store. The goal would be to build something that could move in the same way as a human, but it wouldn't necessarily need to be shaped like one. If we had some space-age synthetic muscle, we could rig it up to actually move. What kind of joint would you need for the shoulder? What would you make a vertebra out of, and how would it connect to its neighbor and how would it move? How would you construct a pelvis so that there were joints in the proper places?
The good news is that we don't actually need to build this machine- it's very helpful just to plan it out mentally. The more accurately and true-to-life we can plan this machine, the better our understanding of the figure will be. The bad news is that as two-dimensional artists we need to be able to draw it. We don't necessarily need to be able to draw the actual parts we'd get from the hardware store- we can use some imaginary parts that have the same types of mechanical movement, and we can use simple masses for the bones.
This inevitably gets back to perspective. It's not enough to understand what a particular joint would be, we also need to be able to draw that joint and the major axes of the bones involved from any angle. Further, once we draw two joints, we also need them to be arranged in a way that would make sense given a single, fixed viewpoint and the ranges of motion for the joints involved. One of the most common errors in figure drawing is drawing the different masses in a way that implies either that either the joints are in the wrong location or moved past their possible range of motion, or that the masses are in fact being viewed from different viewpoints.
Let's take one of the more simple joints in the skeleton- the elbow joint of the humerus and ulna. In other words, the joint that allows you to bend your forearm up to do a bicep curl. If we ignored the radius for now (which allows you rotate your palm), we could build this joint very simply for our machine: just a couple two-by-fours and a regular door hinge. When drawing, we can represent it with a long, thin box for the humerus, a long, thin box for the ulna, and an imaginary cylinder joint between them for the hinge. Assuming the "elbow" isn't bent, things are pretty easy to draw, right? From the sides and front, it's a piece of cake. You could probably even tip it around in space fairly easily as well.
However, once we bend that elbow a bit, things get complicated. From the sides it's not too hard, and using that information we can estimate the front view fairly well (we're fudging the foreshortening). But once we rotate our bent contraption, we get into trouble:
See? Right away we are back at perspective. How would you solve this particular problem? If you have no idea, then how are you going to draw the arm in a similar position? Even if you have the model posing in front of you, it's beneficial to understand that this particular perspective problem is at play. If the pose is short enough, you will need this understanding to get something legible down quickly. If the pose is longer (particularly if there are multiple breaks) you will need this understanding to compensate for shifts in the pose.
This is for one of the simplest joints in the body. It's further complicated by the fact that the ulna does not actually line up with the axis of movement created by the cylinder joint- it's slightly skewed off in what's called the "carrying angle" of the lower arm (named because it allows space to carry objects such as a full bucket without it hitting your thigh). To complicate things even more, the carrying angle varies from person to person, especially between men and women (due to the relatively wider pelvis and narrower shoulders of the female skeleton). And we haven't even thrown in the radius.
A good first step to this kind of understanding is to start planning out your human machine, and understanding how to represent it in 3-dimensional space from a fixed viewpoint. Start simple. Start with what you understand. When you find a gap in your understanding, look for an answer. When you find a discrepancy between your mental machine and the model or a piece of reference, adjust the design for your machine accordingly. Let your machine evolve along with your understanding. As it does, you'll find both drawing from the figure and from imagination much less mystifying.
Monday, February 22, 2010
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Perspective and the Figure - Part 1
This is based on a post I wrote over at ConceptArt.org a few months ago.
Realistic drawing in the Western tradition is dependent on the idea of a fixed viewpoint and the relation of all forms in the picture plane to that viewpoint. This is really what perspective is. Imagine a box facing you at eye level- you will only see its front plane. Move it straight to one side and you will see its side plane and its front plane. Move it straight down from there and you will see the top, side, and front planes. But then, if you keep it in that same location but rotate in certain ways, you might only see its front plane again.
This, combined with the idea of diminishing, is the heart of perspective. The exact implementation of this is all the vanishing points and horizon lines and eye levels and all that. While those things are very important to know, they're really secondary to this idea of the fixed viewpoint*. When you're drawing the figure, it's too complicated to figure out most of the vanishing points- you have to understand the first part well enough to estimate the effects of perspective on a given form. Figure drawing pretty much boils down to a complicated puzzle involving the cube example from above for each form of the body- but each form is much more complicated than a box. These forms change shape based on muscle flexion and forces from the environment, and are oriented in complicated ways dictated by the joints of the skeletal structure. Just take the most basic pose: a person of your height standing straight up facing you, with their eyes at your eye level. You will see the tops of their feet and shoulders, but not the top of their head.
Along with studying buildings and the other usual suspects in perspective, practice the simple rounded forms (cylinder, cone, sphere) bounded by a box from every possible angle, then move on to more complicated forms like vases. Really understand how each form fits within the box, and what happens to the ellipses in all possible cases. Then move on to more complex assymetrical forms with cross-sections that aren't circular. Most people blow this off thinking they understand it, but strangely can't draw a proper cylinder and unsurprisingly can't draw a figure except for a few static & memorized poses. It's easy to understand but hard to do properly.
The idea is to work out all the scenarios carefully ahead of time, so that when the model is in front of you don't need to spend time figuring it out then and there. What is a calf but a strangely shaped vase? And if you can't draw a simple vase tipped toward you in perspective without a lot of headache, how are you going to get the job done with the model in front of you (and probably with much less time)?
Spend the time up front and get these perspective scenarios into your vocabulary, so you're able to use them "conversationally" while drawing. It's important to be able to think this way, but not be mechanical about it.
* I recently found Bruce MacEvoy's excellent (but technical) articles on perspective over at handprint.com, and was pleased to see that he explicitly breaks out the Stationary Viewer as the first step in creating a perspective view.
Realistic drawing in the Western tradition is dependent on the idea of a fixed viewpoint and the relation of all forms in the picture plane to that viewpoint. This is really what perspective is. Imagine a box facing you at eye level- you will only see its front plane. Move it straight to one side and you will see its side plane and its front plane. Move it straight down from there and you will see the top, side, and front planes. But then, if you keep it in that same location but rotate in certain ways, you might only see its front plane again.
This, combined with the idea of diminishing, is the heart of perspective. The exact implementation of this is all the vanishing points and horizon lines and eye levels and all that. While those things are very important to know, they're really secondary to this idea of the fixed viewpoint*. When you're drawing the figure, it's too complicated to figure out most of the vanishing points- you have to understand the first part well enough to estimate the effects of perspective on a given form. Figure drawing pretty much boils down to a complicated puzzle involving the cube example from above for each form of the body- but each form is much more complicated than a box. These forms change shape based on muscle flexion and forces from the environment, and are oriented in complicated ways dictated by the joints of the skeletal structure. Just take the most basic pose: a person of your height standing straight up facing you, with their eyes at your eye level. You will see the tops of their feet and shoulders, but not the top of their head.
Along with studying buildings and the other usual suspects in perspective, practice the simple rounded forms (cylinder, cone, sphere) bounded by a box from every possible angle, then move on to more complicated forms like vases. Really understand how each form fits within the box, and what happens to the ellipses in all possible cases. Then move on to more complex assymetrical forms with cross-sections that aren't circular. Most people blow this off thinking they understand it, but strangely can't draw a proper cylinder and unsurprisingly can't draw a figure except for a few static & memorized poses. It's easy to understand but hard to do properly.
The idea is to work out all the scenarios carefully ahead of time, so that when the model is in front of you don't need to spend time figuring it out then and there. What is a calf but a strangely shaped vase? And if you can't draw a simple vase tipped toward you in perspective without a lot of headache, how are you going to get the job done with the model in front of you (and probably with much less time)?
Spend the time up front and get these perspective scenarios into your vocabulary, so you're able to use them "conversationally" while drawing. It's important to be able to think this way, but not be mechanical about it.
* I recently found Bruce MacEvoy's excellent (but technical) articles on perspective over at handprint.com, and was pleased to see that he explicitly breaks out the Stationary Viewer as the first step in creating a perspective view.
Saturday, February 6, 2010
Quick & Dirty Division
Dividing things visually is pretty critical for drawing- a teacher of mine used to go so far as to say "Drawing is division". When doodling in your sketchbook, it's easy to start with a head, maybe add a torso, and if you feel like it (and there's still room on the page) you can throw in some legs. But when you start thinking compositionally, you need to be able to say "The figure goes here". That is to say, it needs to fit within a certain spot on the page or the greater composition in order to create a good whole.
When it comes to that point, it's critical to start thinking in terms of division. Unfortunately, humans are pretty terrible at dividing anything other than in half- and they're not very good at that over large distances. Head lengths, a common proportional device, fail us pretty quickly. Unless the figure is 8 head-lengths, which is convenient for division, we can't divide our composition space into some weird number of head lengths that most people are (7.5, 6, 6.5). Proportional dividers and grid transparencies can help with this, but sometimes they're too cumbersome to deal with- especially in quicker poses or when working on larger surfaces.
Plus, all of this is assuming a nice standing figure with little foreshortening. If the model is crouching or reclining, head lengths pretty quickly become useless- even with the proportional divider. In such a case, or if the pose is quick or you don't want to use too many aides in your drawing, you can use this technique to quickly find a halfway point of something. It works on both the model and on your drawing. All you need is a straightedge, which a relatively straight pencil, brush, piece of charcoal, or knitting needle can function as just fine.
When it comes to that point, it's critical to start thinking in terms of division. Unfortunately, humans are pretty terrible at dividing anything other than in half- and they're not very good at that over large distances. Head lengths, a common proportional device, fail us pretty quickly. Unless the figure is 8 head-lengths, which is convenient for division, we can't divide our composition space into some weird number of head lengths that most people are (7.5, 6, 6.5). Proportional dividers and grid transparencies can help with this, but sometimes they're too cumbersome to deal with- especially in quicker poses or when working on larger surfaces.
Plus, all of this is assuming a nice standing figure with little foreshortening. If the model is crouching or reclining, head lengths pretty quickly become useless- even with the proportional divider. In such a case, or if the pose is quick or you don't want to use too many aides in your drawing, you can use this technique to quickly find a halfway point of something. It works on both the model and on your drawing. All you need is a straightedge, which a relatively straight pencil, brush, piece of charcoal, or knitting needle can function as just fine.
- Choose a top and bottom point. If it's your drawing and it's in the beginning stages where there aren't many marks on your page to grab on to, make a small mark at the top and bottom.
- Estimate a halfway point. Don't labor about it- just take your best guess. It's most likely going to be wrong, but it will help us quite a bit nonetheless. If you're measuring on your drawing, put a very faint mark where you think halfway will be. If you're looking at the model or some other subject matter, just choose some landmark on the subject.
- Extending your arm all the way and locking your elbow, take your straightedge and put the end point at your estimated halfway point. Slide your thumb down so it lines up with the bottom mark that you made or decided upon.
- Keeping your arm extended and your elbow locked to minimize forward and back movement, shift your arm up so the end point is now at the top mark.
- Unless you made a very good estimate, your thumb should be above or below your estimated halfway point. Here's the key- halfway between your thumb and the estimated halfway point is the actual halfway point. Since it's a much smaller distance to work with now, you can now estimate a new halfway point based on this new information, which will be significantly more accurate. If you're looking at the subject, find a new landmark to hold on to mentally. If you're measuring on your drawing and there's nothing on the page to grab on to, make a new mark on the piece
- Keeping the end point of your straightedge aligned with your top mark (or putting it back there if you used your straightedge to make a mark), slide your thumb the new & improved estimated halfway point.
- Because we're human, it's good to check out our estimations. Small shifts in our position can make a big difference, as can things significantly above or below our view point. Further, ssuming something is correct that is slightly off can be the death of proportions. The beauty here is that to check things out, you simply have to repeat the process. Go back to step three and repeat until you're satisfied. On a quick drawing I might do this process only once, but on longer drawings I might repeat it several times.
Sunday, January 17, 2010
Mixing Color: One Approach
(This is based on a post I wrote over at ConceptArt.org)
There are many ways to think about mixing paint, and knowing more than one is useful. I might even go so far as to say it's necessary to have multiple mental approaches to mixing paint, and have the ability to switch between them as the situation calls for it. However, here's a good method to get started:
The basic idea is- start with an approximation of the hue, then match value, then match hue more precisely, then match chroma.
Of course, there are complications to this method. The biggest one is that, as written, the hue will likely shift towards blue-purple as you mix if you're using Ivory Black and Titanium white, so you would need to learn to compensate for that. One way is to choose the initial colors slightly shifted away from blue. Another way is to use a more neutral black and white- for example, Cremnitz white and certain brands of Mars black will shift the hues less significantly. You can also use a pre-mixed neutral of black, white, and brown. Note than none of these are foolproof, but they will get you closer. In the end you still need to rely on your own judgment rather than leaving it to the system.
You also need to use some judgment about the chromas of the initial colors you choose- they need to be at least slightly higher in chroma than the color you're trying to hit.
This method can also be a bit slow when painting from the model. As you get used to it, there are lots of shortcuts you can take, or you can use a different method altogether. A few shortcuts:
It's not a magic bullet, but it's a good starting point. It's especially useful if you're used to thinking in HSB on the computer.
I highly recommend http://huevaluechroma.com, a site put together by David Briggs, who teaches out in Australia. It can read like rocket science, but it's good to read and then re-read as you work more. If you do that, more and more of the complicated stuff will make sense. There's a lot of misinformation about color out there, but huevaluechroma.com is all solid, and refreshingly free of bias.
There are many ways to think about mixing paint, and knowing more than one is useful. I might even go so far as to say it's necessary to have multiple mental approaches to mixing paint, and have the ability to switch between them as the situation calls for it. However, here's a good method to get started:
- Choose two colors that "bracket" the hue you are trying to hit- meaning, they are on either side of the hue on the hue wheel. Occasionally one color will hit the hue exactly, but chances are it will lie between two.
- Use white to raise both of these colors to the value you're trying to hit.
- Mix the two lightened mixtures together until they match the hue you are trying to hit more precisely.
- If the chroma (better word for saturation when painting) is too high, mix black and white together to the value of the mixture.
- Use this gray mixture to bring the chroma down to the chroma you're trying to hit.
The basic idea is- start with an approximation of the hue, then match value, then match hue more precisely, then match chroma.
Of course, there are complications to this method. The biggest one is that, as written, the hue will likely shift towards blue-purple as you mix if you're using Ivory Black and Titanium white, so you would need to learn to compensate for that. One way is to choose the initial colors slightly shifted away from blue. Another way is to use a more neutral black and white- for example, Cremnitz white and certain brands of Mars black will shift the hues less significantly. You can also use a pre-mixed neutral of black, white, and brown. Note than none of these are foolproof, but they will get you closer. In the end you still need to rely on your own judgment rather than leaving it to the system.
You also need to use some judgment about the chromas of the initial colors you choose- they need to be at least slightly higher in chroma than the color you're trying to hit.
This method can also be a bit slow when painting from the model. As you get used to it, there are lots of shortcuts you can take, or you can use a different method altogether. A few shortcuts:
- Premix neutrals from black to white in equal steps, which saves time for steps 4 & 5 and also give you "targets" to match the colors to.
- Also premix the colors to the same values, which saves time in steps 1 & 2.
- Be less rigid about the order
- Adjust chroma by choosing initial colors that are further away from each other on the hue wheel (this can be unpredictable, but with experience you can learn to control this).
- Supplement this method with another method of mixing color.
It's not a magic bullet, but it's a good starting point. It's especially useful if you're used to thinking in HSB on the computer.
I highly recommend http://huevaluechroma.com, a site put together by David Briggs, who teaches out in Australia. It can read like rocket science, but it's good to read and then re-read as you work more. If you do that, more and more of the complicated stuff will make sense. There's a lot of misinformation about color out there, but huevaluechroma.com is all solid, and refreshingly free of bias.
Monday, January 4, 2010
The Value Scale
It can be very useful to assign numbers to even steps value, often referred to as a value scale. I learned to use an eleven-step value scale- 0-10, with zero being black and 10 being white. The number of steps doesn't really matter, nor does which end is white (some people have 0 as white). But, it helps to pick something and stick with it, since you can then build a library of values to expect for different subjects in different lighting situations.
For example, when I go to paint a model under an artificial fluorescent light, I can expect that a lighter skinned model might have something close to a 3 for the shadow value, going up to an 8. For a darker skinned model the shadow might be closer to 1 or 2, with the main lights around 6 or 7 and highlights approaching 8 or 9. These values might change depending on the exact setup. For example, a light source within the scene might force the light values on the figure to compress down further to leave room for the light source to appear relatively very light in comparison.
It's also useful for keeping values consistent and properly differentiating values. For example, under most circumstances the shadow area will not be as light as the areas in light- even most reflected lights can't reach as high a value. So once you've determined the darkest number in the light, you can make sure to always use a darker number for everything in shadow.
The concept is bit difficult to get used to in transparent mediums such as graphite or watercolor because it's difficult to know when you're at a 5 versus a 6. However, in oil paint it's easy to pre-mix colors in equal steps. You can eyeball it, or mix it to match a predetermined grayscale- either from a good inkjet printer, or from a standard grayscale such as the one determined by Munsell System.
Once you're used to the idea in oil, it can be translated to a transparent medium, although it generally is not as exact- often the darkest dark in a drawing changes slightly as a drawing progresses, and thus it's tough to determine what your 0 value is and how the others should relate. As such, there's a period at the beginning where the value scale is a bit nebulous. It can be useful to draw a quick scale on a small piece of the same paper your drawing is on and compare the values in your drawing to this scale to determine the value numbers. Or, you can keep things more fluid and let the scale evolve naturally. Either way, it's useful to decide which pencils are associated with each value- generally you want to leave the harder pencils for the lighter values, and add softer pencils to the darker values (though you can still use the harder pencils over the soft to smooth things out).
It's worth noting that you don't have to be deadly precise with this for it to be useful, and you don't always need to stick to whole numbers. In some paintings it becomes clear that a value must be between two steps, and in some lighting situations the darks or lights might be so compressed that you can't use the whole steps.
For example, when I go to paint a model under an artificial fluorescent light, I can expect that a lighter skinned model might have something close to a 3 for the shadow value, going up to an 8. For a darker skinned model the shadow might be closer to 1 or 2, with the main lights around 6 or 7 and highlights approaching 8 or 9. These values might change depending on the exact setup. For example, a light source within the scene might force the light values on the figure to compress down further to leave room for the light source to appear relatively very light in comparison.
It's also useful for keeping values consistent and properly differentiating values. For example, under most circumstances the shadow area will not be as light as the areas in light- even most reflected lights can't reach as high a value. So once you've determined the darkest number in the light, you can make sure to always use a darker number for everything in shadow.
The concept is bit difficult to get used to in transparent mediums such as graphite or watercolor because it's difficult to know when you're at a 5 versus a 6. However, in oil paint it's easy to pre-mix colors in equal steps. You can eyeball it, or mix it to match a predetermined grayscale- either from a good inkjet printer, or from a standard grayscale such as the one determined by Munsell System.
Once you're used to the idea in oil, it can be translated to a transparent medium, although it generally is not as exact- often the darkest dark in a drawing changes slightly as a drawing progresses, and thus it's tough to determine what your 0 value is and how the others should relate. As such, there's a period at the beginning where the value scale is a bit nebulous. It can be useful to draw a quick scale on a small piece of the same paper your drawing is on and compare the values in your drawing to this scale to determine the value numbers. Or, you can keep things more fluid and let the scale evolve naturally. Either way, it's useful to decide which pencils are associated with each value- generally you want to leave the harder pencils for the lighter values, and add softer pencils to the darker values (though you can still use the harder pencils over the soft to smooth things out).
It's worth noting that you don't have to be deadly precise with this for it to be useful, and you don't always need to stick to whole numbers. In some paintings it becomes clear that a value must be between two steps, and in some lighting situations the darks or lights might be so compressed that you can't use the whole steps.
Labels:
graphite,
Munsell System,
oil painting,
value scale,
values,
watercolor
Friday, January 1, 2010
Notes: Modeling Factors
The concept of modeling factors builds on the idea of the poster. Within an individual form, the artist decides on a certain number of steps to use in the poster, and these steps correspond to the progression of values one sees in chiaroscuro. Again, the exact number of steps depends on the artist on the technique being used. For example, in more naturalistic techniques the artist might use as many as twelve modeling factors, but in a more impressionist technique five or six modeling factors might be sufficient.
These five modeling factors are quite efficient at representing forms, and are a good base for realistic paintings:
To create a very convincing representation of form and surface more modeling factors might be needed. In such a case, it can be useful to divide the light, halftone, and shadow areas into smaller and more specific modeling factors. For example:
These five modeling factors are quite efficient at representing forms, and are a good base for realistic paintings:
- Shadow (or Tone)- This area is all parts of the form that are parallel to the direction of the light source or further. It also includes cast shadows.
- Light - The area of the form generally facing the light.
- Halftone - Between the tone and light. While the light and shadow together establish the overall mass of the object, the halftone is critical for defining the more precise shape of the object.
- Highlight - A specular reflection of the light source. This differs from the light in that it usually will not appear where the form is facing the light, but rather in the spot where the light source would show if the form were a mirror.
- Depth (or Accent) - These are areas where very little light is reaching. Particularly when the light is from above, there will be small pockets where very little light reaches. Generally they are found in the shadow areas, but do also occur in the light where two forms or subforms overlap each other dramatically. For example, underneath the edge of a cloth laying on a table you will usually find a dark line- this is a depth. They're also often found where the feet touch the ground, where necklines and cuffs of clothing overlap the figure, and in crevices like the armpit and the crotch. Depths are quite valuable for showing one form sitting on top of another.
To create a very convincing representation of form and surface more modeling factors might be needed. In such a case, it can be useful to divide the light, halftone, and shadow areas into smaller and more specific modeling factors. For example:
- Highlight
- Light Light
- Middle Light
- Dark Light
- Light Halftone
- Middle Halftone
- Dark Halftone
- Terminator (the division between the halftone and shadow)
- Dark Dark
- Medium Dark
- Light Dark
- Depth
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
Notes: The Poster
The poster is a geometric simplification of the value structure of your image. Each form is built up of myriad gradations, which can be difficult to comprehend. The poster simplifies these gradations made up of hundreds or thousands of steps of value into a much smaller and more manageable number of steps. How many steps is up to the artist, and can be quite flexible depending on subject matter and the technique being used.
The idea is to ignore the gradations at first and instead focus on the patterns that the gradations are making. Is it a smooth transition from light to dark? Does it get gradually darker most of the way and then suddenly shift more quickly at the end? Does it shift from dark to light and back to dark? How do all these shifts correspond to the contour?
Thinking of what the gradations are doing and putting them down in steps allows us to analyze the progression of values without worrying about the technique of making the smooth gradations. There are all sorts of ways to make the gradations later, but it's important to understand what's happening in them first.
The idea is to ignore the gradations at first and instead focus on the patterns that the gradations are making. Is it a smooth transition from light to dark? Does it get gradually darker most of the way and then suddenly shift more quickly at the end? Does it shift from dark to light and back to dark? How do all these shifts correspond to the contour?
Thinking of what the gradations are doing and putting them down in steps allows us to analyze the progression of values without worrying about the technique of making the smooth gradations. There are all sorts of ways to make the gradations later, but it's important to understand what's happening in them first.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

